The European Commission Adopts New Adequacy Decision for EU-US Privacy Framework.

Chogwu Enape
4 min readJul 14, 2023

On July 10, 2023, the European Commission (EC) announced the adoption of a new adequacy decision concerning the EU-US privacy framework. This decision comes as a response to the evolving landscape of data privacy and the need to ensure the protection of personal data in transatlantic data transfers. The new framework aims to address the shortcomings of previous arrangements and strengthen the privacy rights of individuals while facilitating data flows between the European Union (EU) and the United States (US).

The Need for a Third Privacy Framework.

The previous privacy frameworks, namely the EU-US Safe Harbor and its successor, the EU-US Privacy Shield, faced criticisms and legal challenges regarding the level of protection they provided to personal data transferred from the EU to the US. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) invalidated both frameworks, highlighting concerns over US surveillance practices and the lack of adequate safeguards for EU citizens’ personal data. Consequently, there was a pressing need to establish a new privacy framework to address these issues and restore trust in transatlantic data transfers.

Key Changes:

The new adequacy decision incorporates several changes to enhance data protection. One of these changes is the introduction of enhanced scrutiny of US government surveillance practices, ensuring that they align with the EU’s standards for privacy and data protection. Additionally, the new framework strengthens individual rights by providing EU citizens with effective redress mechanisms in case of privacy violations.

Criticisms:

Despite these improvements, the decision has faced criticism from privacy advocates and some EU member states. Critics argue that the new framework still fails to fully address concerns related to US surveillance activities and the lack of judicial remedies for EU citizens. They express concerns over the potential impact on the privacy rights of individuals and the potential for data misuse by US authorities.

Impact of the adequacy decision on companies self-certifying under the DPF and companies. already self-certified under the now obsolete Privacy Shield:

For companies self-certifying under the Digital Privacy Framework (DPF), the new adequacy decision means there will not be any need for transfer risk assessments or additional transfer mechanisms such as an SCC or a BCR. However, they must remain vigilant and ensure ongoing compliance with the DPF’s requirements and any future updates.

Companies that are self-certified under the Privacy Shield and wish to participate in the DPF are required to reassess their privacy practices and align them with the new framework’s requirements. They must demonstrate adherence to the enhanced safeguards and individual rights provisions outlined in the adequacy decision.

The adequacy decision and transferring Personal Data under SCCs or BCRs:

Companies that transfer personal data under Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) or Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) will continue to rely on these mechanisms for data transfers between the EU and the US. The new adequacy decision does not affect the validity of SCCs or BCRs, as they provide supplementary safeguards for data protection. However, companies should ensure that their SCCs or BCRs reflect the changes introduced in the new framework to maintain compliance.

Strategy Options for EU Companies to Ensure Compliance:

To ensure compliance with the new adequacy decision, EU companies can consider the following strategies:

1. Conduct a thorough privacy assessment: Evaluate data flows and ensure that personal data transfers to the US comply with the enhanced safeguards provided by the new framework.

2. Update privacy policies and procedures: Revise internal policies and procedures to align with the new adequacy decision’s requirements, including enhanced redress mechanisms and rights for individuals.

3. Review data transfer mechanisms: Assess existing SCCs or BCRs to ensure they incorporate the provisions of the new EU-US Data privacy framework, and make any necessary updates or amendments.

4. Stay informed and proactive: Monitor regulatory developments and guidance from data protection authorities to stay up-to-date with evolving compliance requirements.

The new adequacy decision for the EU-US privacy framework represents a step towards restoring trust in transatlantic data transfers. While it addresses some of the reprovals of previous frameworks, the new EU-US data privacy framework also faces specific criticisms regarding US surveillance practices and individual rights. Companies self-certifying under the DPF or transitioning from the Privacy Shield must ensure ongoing compliance, while those relying on SCCs or BCRs should update their mechanisms accordingly. By taking a proactive approach to compliance, EU companies can navigate the new framework successfully and protect the privacy of individuals’ personal data.

--

--

Chogwu Enape

Researcher, writer, and the ultimate idealist. One day I moved to Paris and many things have happened to me since then.